|
Today's
Stories
June 15, 2007
Andy
Worthington
The Ordeal of Ali al-Marri
John
Ross
Ballot Burning Time in Ol' Mexico
June 14, 2007
Michael
Donnelly
Charred SUVs and the End
of Citizen Eco-Activism
Faisal
Kutty
Scare Canada: The No-Fly List's
False Sense of Security
Harry
Browne
Ireland's Green Party Sells
Out
Charles
Jonkel
From the Arctic to Yellowstone: Bears in a World of Indifference
Steven
Higgs
Murder in a Small Town: "Gay
Panic" in Indiana?
Bruce
Dixon
Black Power Through Low Power
Radio
Bruce
K. Gagnon
What Do We Do Now? A 10-Step
Plan for Antiwar Activists
Website
of the Day
Finkelgate
June
13, 2007
Glen
Ford
Obama's
Siren Song
Marjorie
Cohn
Repression
in Oaxaca
Bill
Christison
A Grave Injustice at DePaul University
Silvia
Cattori
"I Was Not Prepared for the Horrors I Saw": an Interview
with Hedy Epstein
Richard
Gott
Racism and TV in Venezuela
Firmin
DeBrabander
How the Neocons Misread Machiavelli
William
S. Lind
The Perfect (Sine) Wave: Bombing Railroad Stations in Iraq
Keith
Rosenthal
Workers Score a Victory at Harvard
Website
of the Day
GOP and Monty Python Explain: "Enhanced Interrogation Techniques"
June
12, 2007
Jeffrey
St. Clair
How
to Sell a War
Paul
Craig Roberts
The Neocon Threat to American Freedom
P.
Sainath
India's
Plutocrats and the Press
Ralph
Nader
The Biggest Scam in the World
Omar
Waraich
A Black Day for Pakistan's Press
Dave
Lindorff
Things Your Media Momma Didn't Tell You
Harvey
Wasserman
Confessions of an Anti-Nuke Jerk
Malini
Johar Schueller
It Takes a Bomb
Ramzy
Baroud
War Foretold: Mark Twain and the Sins of Empire
Website
of the Day
Palestinian Chronicle Needs Our Help!
June
11, 2007
Patrick
Cockburn
The
War on Journalists
Paul
Craig Roberts
Losing the Economy to Mythology
Uri
Avnery
40 Bad Years: the Rot of Occupation
Norman
Solomon
The Silence of the Bombs
Eva
Liddell
Paris Hilton Doesn't Do Dishes: How Barbie Stood Up to Allen Ginsberg
Rannie
Amiri
Groundhog Day in Pakistan
Rachel
Voss
Poetry and Politics in Nassau County
Christopher
Brauchli
A Wild West Tale, Starring Rev. Dobson and Bill O'Reilly
D.
K. Wilson
Untangling Michael Vick from the Dogs
Website
of the Day
Paris, Mixed Up
June 9 / 10, 2007
Alexander
Cockburn
Dissidents
Against Dogma
George
Ciccariello-Maher
Behind
Venezuela's "Student Rebellion": Who's Pulling the Strings?
Saul
Landau
An
Interview with Ricardo Alarcon, Vice President of Cuba
Robert
Fisk
Believe It or Not in the Middle East
Brian
Cloughley
Troop Support: Deceptions and Insipid Sentiments
Ron
Jacobs
Condoleezza Rice Names the System
Ward
Boston
Searching for the Truth About the USS Liberty
Conn
Hallinan
Dark Plots in Byzantine Beirut
Leonard
Peltier
The Ongoing War on Native American Religious Practices
Lawrence
Davidson
Israel's New Anti-Boycott Task Force
John
Ross
Mass Nude-In Complicates Church-State Scuffling in Mexico
Kate
Allan
Some People Think the Internet is a Bad Thing
Fred
Gardner
Ignorance Marches On
Stephen
Fleischman
Little Boy, Fat Man and Iran
Monica
Benderman
Reading Tom Paine in a Time of Crisis
Geoff
Bailey
A Real Oil Conspiracy: Gouged at the Pump
Missy
Beattie
Faith and War
Patrick
Dyer
A Democrat Revs Up Ohio's Death Machine
Tim
Lengerich
Dispelling the Cowboy Myth: an Interview with George Wuerthner
James
Irani
and David Rahni
Perspectives on the Arrests of Iran-Americans in Tehran
Gary
Leupp
The Unfair Treatment of Paris Hilton
Michael
Tillery
The Heart of a Sportswriter: an Interview with David Aldridge
Michael
Simmons
Beating Off the Squares: the Hipness of Anton Rosenberg
Poets'
Basement
Laymon, Davies and Ford
Website
of the Weekend
This is Sea Shepherd!
June
8, 2007
Serge
Halimi
What
Sarkozy Learned About Politics from the US
Patrick
Cockburn
The Turkish Incursion
Jeffrey
St. Clair
Israel's Attack on the USS Liberty, Revisited
Paul
Craig Roberts
The Secret War
William
Blum
What If NBC Cheered on a Military Coup Against Bush?
Joshua
Frank
Swing-State Strategy: Looking for a Spoiler
Lance
Selfa
How the Six Day War Changed the Middle East
Dave
Lindorff
A "Criminal Conspiracy" in the White House
Lawrence
Ferlinghetti
The Summer of Love: Flashbacks of a Human Be-In
Website
of the Day
Robert Pollin: "Making the Federal Minimum Wage a Living Wage"
June 7, 2007
Marjorie
Cohn
The
Prison is the War Crime
Soldz,
Reisner and Olson:
A Q & A on Psychologists and Torture
Soldz,
Reisner
and Olson, et al:
An
Open Letter to Sharon Brehm, President of the American Psychological
Association
Paul
Craig Roberts
Losing Iraq, Nuking Iran
Bill
Quigley
"How Long Must We Support a Mistake?"
Silvia
Cattori
Sailing to Gaza
Carl
G. Estabrook
What the June Bug Is: Politics in the Dismal Season
Ellen
Taylor
Free the Tweakers!: The Good News About Meth
Corporate
Crime Reporter
BAE Systems, Prince Bandar and the $2 Billion Account at the Riggs
Bank
Brenda
Norrell
Torture Training at Ft. Huachuca: Two Priests Face Prison for Exposing
Torture in Arizona
D.
K. Wilson
What Gary Sheffield Really Said
Kevin
Zeese
Iraq Occupation Coming to a Head Over Oil
Website
of the Day
How the Press Expired
June 6, 2007
Alain
Gresh
Countdown
to War on Iran
Gary
Leupp
Poddy's Crazy Prayer: Bomb Iran, For Israel and America!
Steven
Sherman
The Perils of Humanitarian Intervention
Bruce
Dixon
Is Bill Gates Trying to Hijack Africa's Food Supply?
Corporate
Crime Reporter
The Professor and the Nukes
Brian
M. Downing
The Iraq War and Presidential Politics
Ron
Jacobs
Luv n' Hate: a Different Take on the Summer of Love
George
Bisharat
The Mirage of the Two State Solution
Nicole
Colson
Over to You, Dante: Falwell's Ministry of Hate
Bruce
K. Gagnon
From Italy to Guam: A Global Peace Movement is Taking Shape
Website
of the Day
How the Democrats Should Treat Bush
June
5, 2007
Michael
Neumann
Canada
in Afghanistan
Jonathan
Cook
The Shin Bet and the Persecution of Azmi Bishara
David
Vest
The Democrats' War
Robert
Fantina
America's Cuba Policy
Hoffman,
Parsneau and Chowdhury
CounterTerrorism as International Healthcare
John
V. Walsh
Shaming the Official Antiwar Movement
Richard
Cretan
Yellow Dog: The Strange Love of Martin Amis and Tony Blair
Adam
Engel
Days of Dread: an American Tale
William
S. Lind
The News from Anbar: Has Al Qaeda Over-Reached?
Myles
Hoenig
Free the Oaks! Cut Down Those Yellow Ribbons!
Jim
Minick
Lead-Foot Nation
Website
of the Day
Punk Rock Soap Opera
June 4, 2007
Nizar
Latif
An
Interview with Moqtada al-Sadr
Diana
Johnstone
Sarko
and the Ghosts of May, 1968
Gregory
Wilpert
RCTV and Freedom of Speech in Venezuela
Paul
Watson
The Anchorage Whale Killing Bureaucrats Summit
Susan
Rosenthal, MD
How Cindy Sheehan Unmasked the Democrats
Richard
Ward
The Right of Return to New Orleans
Eva
Liddell
Don't Support the Troops
Zahi
Khouri
Four Decades of Occupation
Evelyn
Pringle
The FDA, GlaxoSmithKline and the Avandia Disaster
China
Hand
About Those North Korean Benjamin Franklins ...
Karyn
Strickler
George W. Bush: a "Ficeist" Leader
Website
of the Day
The Guantanamo Files
June
2 / 3, 2007
Alexander
Cockburn
The
Last of the Texas Outsiders
Marc
Levy
Iraq
Dead Ahead: a Brief Military History and Civilian Guide to Arlington
National Cemetery
Martin
Smith
Camilo Mejía's War: From Foot Soldier for Empire to Rebel
for Peace
Diana
Johnstone
Great Power Meddling in Kosovo
John
Ross
The Oaxaca Volcano Stews
Uri
Avnery
On Generals and Admirals
Sunsara
Taylor
This is Not a Story About Cindy Sheehan
Richard
Neville
Were the Hippies Right?
P.
Sainath
The Farm Crisis and 100,000 Indian Widows
Missy
Comley Beattie
Let's Roar
Nisrine
Abiad
and Victor Kattan
The Hariri Tribunal: a Fait Accompli?
Rannie
Amiri
Lebanon, Bush and the Three Stooges
Margot
Pepper
Deconstructing "Return to Sender"
Eric
Stewart
Censorship and Cop Brutality in the New Bison Wars
Ralph
Nader
The Halberstam Camp
Dan
Bacher
A Victory for the Fish
Shaun
Harkin
and Sandy Boyer
Irish War Protesters on Trial
Richard
Rhames
Selling Five Acres in Crawford
Frederick
Hudson
The Rediscovery of Ella Fitzgerald
Poets'
Basement
Lindorff, Landau and Buknatski
Website
of the Weekend
Gimme Shelter
June 1, 2007
Dave
Marsh
The
FBI and the Godfather (of Soul): James Brown's FBI Files
Saul
Landau
Return
to Cuba: 47 Years Later in Havana
David
Phinney
How the Baghdad Embassy Was Built: Forced Labor and Worker Abuse
Robert
Jensen
The Bigot and the Boycott
Stanley
Heller
Arrest Robert McNamara
Yifat
Susskind
Indigenous Women Fight Back
Robert
Weissman
Corporate Power Since 1980
Paul
Buchheit
Africa and Its Discontents
William
S. Lind
The Folly of Maximalist Objectives
Sherwood
Ross
78,000 Iraqis Have Been Killed by Coalition Airstrikes
Stephen
Lendman
Terrorism Defined
Website
of the Day
Desert Autonomous Zone
|
June 15, 2007
Another Legal Blow to the Bush
Administration
The
Ordeal of Ali al-Marri
By ANDY
WORTHINGTON
There
used to be a belief – no doubt Attorney General Alberto Gonzales
would describe it as “quaint” – that people accused
of a crime were presumed innocent until proven guilty. That was
in the olden days, however, before the world-changing events of
9/11, after which, according to the powers that the President of
the United States granted himself in November 2001, anyone he regarded
with suspicion – almost exclusively Muslims, as it turned
out – could be declared guilty without the need for such outmoded
legal relics as the presumption of innocence and the right to a
fair trial.
The
prison at Guantánamo is full of these new types of human
beings – “illegal enemy combatants,” guilty “unpeople”
imprisoned forever at the President’s whim – as are
other US-run prisons around the world, in Afghanistan, Iraq, Diego
Garcia and the Horn of Africa. Some are hidden in prisons in other
countries – “friendly” regimes who are “with
us” in the “War on Terror,” including Libya, a
country run by a man who resembles, but clearly is not the Colonel
Gaddafi who was once our sworn enemy – where they can be subjected
to “enhanced interrogation techniques” without American
operatives having to lift a finger to incriminate themselves in
their “interrogation.”
On
Monday 11 June, the case of one of these “unpeople”
– a Qatari named Ali al-Marri, a rather special example who
was captured in the United States – was scrutinized by a panel
of Fourth Circuit judges, who were deciding whether the President
had the right to have kept this man imprisoned without trial for
five and a half years. To an untrained eye – perhaps one belonging
to those of us who still believe in due process – the facts
in al-Marri’s case are difficult to discern with any certainty,
beyond the documented evidence relating to his movements between
September 2001 and the present day.
A
legal US resident – though not a citizen – al-Marri
had studied computer science at Bradley University in Peoria, Illinois
in 1991, and returned on 10 September 2001 to pursue post-graduate
studies, bringing his family – his wife and five children
– with him. Three months later he was arrested and charged
with fraud and making false statements to the FBI, but in June 2003,
a month before he was due to stand trial for these charges in a
federal court in Peoria, the prosecution dropped the charges and
informed the court that he was to be held as an “enemy combatant”
instead. Held incommunicado in a military brig in Charleston, South
Carolina, he was not allowed to meet representatives of the International
Red Cross until August 2004, and was not allowed legal counsel until
October 2004, when Mark Berman of Gibbons, Del Deo, Dolan, Griffinger
& Vecchione took on his case. Since November 2005, when another
American “enemy combatant,” Jose Padilla, was indicted
on criminal charges unrelated to the alleged terrorist plot for
which he was originally seized in May 2002, al-Marri has had the
dubious distinction of being the only “enemy combatant”
on the US mainland.
On
Monday, al-Marri’s ongoing legal limbo was finally addressed
when the Fourth Circuit judges ruled, by 2-1, that the President
no longer had the right to hold him without charge or trial. “Put
simply, the Constitution does not allow the President to order the
military to seize civilians residing within the United States and
then detain them indefinitely without criminal process,” the
court said, “and this is so even if he calls them 'enemy combatants’.”
Like
the recent debacle of the Military Commissions, this was a painful
blow for an administration clinging to its belief in the Presidential
prerogative to create “enemy combatants” at will. To
bolster its extra-legal case, the charges against al-Marri had been
widely publicized by the administration over the previous four years.
The presidential order which declared him an “enemy combatant”
stated that he was closely associated with al-Qaeda and presented
“a continuing, present, and grave danger to the national security
of the United States,” and at various times he has been accused
of having connections to the al-Qaeda financier Mustafa al-Hawsawi,
of working as an al-Qaeda sleeper agent in the US, of having pledged
to Osama bin Laden that he would kill Americans, and of having documents
related to jihadi activities on his computer, including information
on hydrogen cyanide (used in chemical weapons), lectures by Osama
bin Laden and a cartoon of planes crashing into the World Trade
Center.
These
allegations may or may not be true, but those of us in the “quaint”
old world of due process believe the Fourth Circuit judges were
absolutely correct to conclude that the mind of Bush alone was not
the appropriate place to make these decisions. In the simple Manichean
world of the President and his supporters, however, the judges’
decision is apparently something akin to high treason. Those whose
opinions are as clear-cut as the President’s include Bradford
Berenson, one of eight associate counsels during Alberto Gonzales'
tenure as White House counsel, who complained in the Wall Street
Journal that, “fueled by the 1960s rights revolution, the
post-civil rights era celebration of judicial power, and the suspicion
and distrust of executive power and military authority after Watergate
and the Vietnam War,” the “pendulum” of the federal
courts was “now swinging too far in the other direction.”
Berenson
proceeded to describe al-Marri in terms of such rigorous certitude
that I can only conclude that he was reading the President’s
mind: “Mr Marri is a member of al-Qaeda who trained at Osama
bin Laden's terrorist training camp in Afghanistan. In the summer
of 2001, he met with Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the mastermind of the
Sept. 11 attacks, and then traveled to the U.S. just prior to those
attacks to serve as an al-Qaeda sleeper agent. The government believes
he was intended to be part of a second wave of attacks on our country
and was researching ways to disrupt the US financial system. After
he was arrested, the government searched his computer and found
materials relating to chemical weapons, jihad, and al-Qaeda, as
well as 1,000 credit-card numbers.”
To
Mr Berenson – and his idols in the government – I can
only say: Ali al-Marri may be all of these things, but we need lawyers,
judges and juries to figure that out, not self-declared clairvoyants
with an iron belief in unfettered executive power.
Andy
Worthington (www.andyworthington.co.uk)
is a British historian, and the author of ‘The Guantánamo
Files: The Stories of the 774 Detainees in America’s Illegal
Prison’ (to be published by Pluto Press in October 2007).
He can be reached at: andy@andyworthington.co.uk
|
New From CounterPunch
Books
The Secret Language
of the Crossroads:
HOW THE IRISH
INVENTED SLANG
By Daniel Cassidy
Now Available!
How the Press Failed
The Gang's
All Here: Judy Miller, Bob Woodward, Jeffrey Goldberg, Rupert
Murdoch, Bill O'Reilly...End
Times
Leaves No Reputation Unstained!

Buy End Times Now!
Now Available
from
CounterPunch Books!
Saul Landau's
Bush and Botox World
with a Foreword
by Gore Vidal

Click Here to Order!
The Case Against
Israel
By Michael Neumann
Click Here to Order Michael Neumann's Devastating
Rebuttal of Alan Dershowitz
Grand
Theft Pentagon:
Tales of Greed and Profiteering in the War on Terror
by Jeffrey St. Clair
|