|
April 12,
2003
A
CounterPunch Special Investigation
Wag
the Kennel?
The
Kenneth Joseph Story
by
CAROL LIPTON
with
special assistance from Adam Sacks
On March 21, veteran right-wing journalist Arnaud
de Borchgrave, Paris Bureau Chief for Newsweek for 23 years,
and now United Press International (UPI) Editor at Large, wrote
from the International Desk in Amman Jordan that "a group
of American anti-war demonstrators who came to Iraq with Japanese
human shield volunteers made it across the border today with
14 hours of uncensored video", and that Kenneth Joseph,
a young American pastor with the Assyrian Church of the East,
told UPI the trip "had shocked me back to reality'".
[1]
On March 23, 2003, The Washington Times
ran an identical article by de Borchgrave, also from Amman, Jordan
via UPI, stating that the "American anti-war demonstrators"
who were accompanied by these human shield volunteers had returned
not on March 21, but on March 22. [2]
This time, de Borchgrave described Kenneth
Joseph, not as an American antiwar demonstrator, but as a "young
American pastor of the Assyrian Church of the East", who
was Included in the group of antiwar demonstrators . Joseph's
itensely emotional transformation from dedicated antiwar activist
into ardent supporter of the war in Iraq was attributed to those
interviews. Within 3 days, the right wing media was saturated
with this story, which also received coverage in the mainstream
press.
Incredibly, nowhere has a single photo
or segment from these 14 hours of interviews been published,
nor do any other journalists who have covered this story claimed
that they saw the videos.
The Washington Times, which published
the first stories on Joseph, is owned by the Rev. Sun Myung Moon,
who acquired UPI in 2000.
Reverend Moon is head of a notorious
religious right-wing Christian cult, the Unification Church,
whose fanatical followers, called "moonies", are subjected
to mind-control techniques, as written about by former cult members.[3]
Rev. Moon, whose organization has been the subject of hundreds
of newspaper artiles, stories, and books, was convicted for tax
evasion on July 20, 1984, and was in federal prison, has developed
close ties with the Reagan and both Bush administrations. [4]
The founding editor of the Washington
Times, James Whelan, has spoken out against the Moon organization
since resigning his position due to manipulation from Moon officials.
Rev. Moon's political and business operations were the subject
of a 1992 Frontline special on PBS.
PBS questioned the financial backing
of The Washington Times, which consistently loses approximately
two million dolars a month in operating costs. The Moon organization
has spent an estimtated one billion dollars since it began the
Times, without accounting for its revenue sources.[5]
De Borchgrave, author of "The Spike"
and several other political novels, has been linked to the CIA
and far-right think-tanks and institutions, including the Center
for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS). [6]
On March 26, 2003, The Washington Times
reprinted a Pittsburgh Post-Gazette article by Jack Kelly, a
former Marine and Green Beret, who was deputy assistant secretary
of the Air Force in the Reagan administration, entitled "A
shield decides it's time to turn it in", describing Rev.
Joseph as one of several "repentant" human shields
who had been part of "a group of American anti-war demonstrators,
that joined a Japanese human-shield delegation" in Iraq.
[7]
Johann Hari's Article
On March 27, an article by British journalist
Johann Hari, dateline Amman Jordan and entitled "Spreading
peace at gunpoint", appeared in the Seattle Post-Intelligencer.
Its topic was alsoKenneth Joseph, the "young American pastor"
who was "so convinced that the current war would be waged
against the will of the Iraqi people" that he went to Iraq
to act as a human shield.[8]
He wrote in this highly charged and dramatic
piece that "Joseph was "explaining that his trip had
shocked him back to reality". Yet Hari never states to whom
Joseph did the "explaining", or where. He recounts
Joseph's story as if it were his own, clamining that Iraqis were
"willing to see their own homes demolished" in order
to end Hussein's tyranny, and proceeds to issue a trenchant indictment
of the entire antiwar movement, accusing its members of being
"the real imperialists", for ignoring the "true
wishes" of the Iraqi people.
Hari had already written an essay on
March 26 for the Independent, a progressive British newspaper,
entitled "Sometimes, the only way to spread peace is at
the barrel of a gun", where he describes Joseph as an "ardent
antiwar activist," whose beliefs were "as fervent as
any menber of the Stop the War Coalition". [9]
On March 27, the Washington Times then
published "Dissiolusioned Human Shields", by right-wing
pundit Reed Irvine, head of Accuracy in Media, which is illustrative
of the broadside attacks on the antiwar movement which followed.
[10]
Irvine's story embellished upon de Borchgrave's
account, stating that this group of American antiwar organizers
had "joined a delegation of Japanese human shields"
in Iraq. He describes the group's spokesperson as Kenneth Joseph,
pastor of an obscure religious group, the Assyrian Church of
the East, with "a substantial membership in the United States".
On March 28, Irvine also wrote a piece
for the right wing newsletter NewsMax.com, making reference to
the "plastic shredder" torture methods in Iraq:
"[Rev. Joseph] said that his talks
with Iraqis convinced him that Saddam is "a monster the
likes of which the world had not seen since Stalin and Hitler.
. . Their tales of slow torture and killing made me ill, such
as people put in a huge shredder for plastic products, feet first
so [the torture masters] could hear the screams as bodies got
chewed up from foot to head."[11]
Similar stories, juxtaposing tales of
Saddam's torture with an indictment of peace activists, spread
like wildfire. Other conservative columnists, such as William
F. Buckley's National Review, ran the story, which suddenly appeared
in right wing media throughout the globe. [12]
Kenneth Joseph Unknown
to Human Shield Organizations
The Philadelphia Daily News covered the
human shield expedition from London to Iraq, which comprised
over 200 people from 30 countries travelling in red double-decker
buses on a gueling 3,000 mile10-day trek. They went to guard
civilian sites, such as schools, hospitals, water-treatment facilities
and electrical plants. After the Department of State travel ban
prohibited American citizens from going to Iraq without obtaining
special clearance, all human shield groups needed to apply for
this clearance. [13]
A glaring ommission from these articles
is how Kenneth Joseph obtained State Department clearance, which
he seems to have circumvented as a result of his "invitation
as a religious person and family connections'", and which
spared having a government "minder" tail him 24 hours
a day. [14]
None of the peace organizations or human
shield groups whom I contacted had ever heard of Kenneth Joseph,
nor is his name found on any human shield-related websites. [15]
Who is Kenneth Joseph?
Both Arnaud de Borchgrave, in his two
UPI articles, and Johann Hari, in both the Seattle Post-Intelligencer
and the Independent, describe Kenneth Joseph as an "American
antiwar demonstrator".
In a report posted by the Religious Organizations
Network, entitled "Assyrian Christianity in Japan",
by UCAN Report, Reverend Joseph spoke at a conference on March
16, 1998 in Tokyo, on the history of Christianity in the Far
East. At the conference, he was introduced as "American
Reverend Ken Joseph". [16]
Kenneth Joseph's byline appears on a
March 26 article, datelined Amman, Jordan, entitled "I Was
Wrong", and posted on the Assyrian Christian News website.
He identifies himself not as an American, but as an Assyrian,
born and raised in Japan, whose father [Ken Joseph, Sr.] came
to Japan to rebuild the country after World War II.[17]
He writes that as a minister, "and
due to my personal convictions, I have always been against war
for any and all reasons. It was precisely this moral conviction
that led me to do all I could to stop the current war in Iraq."
He recites with emphasis his antiwar credentials:
"From participating in demonstrations
against the war in Japan to strongly opposing it on my radio
program, on television and in regular columns, I did my best
to stand against what I thought to be an unjust war against an
innocent people - in fact my people". . .".
In an interview in Capitalism Magazine,
he again spoke about "participating in demonstrations against
the war in Japan to strongly opposing it on my radio program,
on television, and in regular columns". [18]
Assyrian Christians.com states that Barbara
Walters will be broadcasting his videotape. [19] Yet, there is
no mention of Kenneth Joseph on the Abc.com index to Barbara
Walters show.
Joseph's biography is posted on the Assyrian
Christian News website. It states that he is pastor at the Narimasu
Christ Church in Tokyo, Japan, founder and director of The Japan
Helpline, a worldwide 24-hour hotline and relief assistance organization,
and founder and director of the Japan-based Keikyo Institute,
which studies the historical roots of Christianity in Asia. [20]
A fundraising appeal for The Keikyo Institute,
seeking to raise a million dollars for this "Christian museum
in Tokyo", can be found on The Christian Broadcasting Network
website. It mentions Ken Joseph's "discovery of the Nestorian
Monument in China," as proof that Assyrian Christians settled
there, and the goal of the fundraising drive was to provide for
the reconstruction of this and other Christian sites in China.
There is no mention whatsoever of peace or antiwar activism.
[21]
Joseph graduated from the Christian Academy
in Japan, and Biola University in La Mirada, California, with
degrees in Intercultural Communictions and Mass Communications,
and after graduation, returned to Japan in 1987, which would
make him at least 37 years old. Yet a recent interview in Japan
Today magazine, discussing his work on the Japan Helpline states
in bold letters that he is 28. [22]
The alumni directory for Biola College
posts an entry for Kenneth Joseph. While he states that he is
a pastor in Japan, directing the Keikyo Institute, has written
3 books, and a weekly column for one of Japan's main newspapers,
nowhere does he mention being a "peace activist". [23]
Joseph's biography also states that he
is currently working on a book about his experiences in Iraq
and the current situation in the Middle East, and in other articles,
he claims to have written a book along with his father on Assyrian
Christians in the Middle East. Yet, nowhere does Amazon.com list
any references to books written by Kenneth Joseph, Jr., nor was
he mentioned on a website email directory of Assyrian authors.
Joseph wrote an article entitled "The
Forgotten Christians", posted on October 29, 2002 to Church
of the East News.com, which credits him as a "writer and
Assyrian Missionary in Japan". It lists his address c/o
The Keikyo Institute, which his bio says is in Japan, as being
in California (Box 16351, Sierra Madre, CA 91104), with an email
address, Info@Church of the East.com. Nowhere does this article
even hint at fervent antiwar activity, despite the fact that
the article begins "with signs of war with Iraq increasing
every day". [24]
Joseph presents a detailed history of
the Assyrian Christians, whom he claims still speak Aramaic,
the language spoken by Jesus. He then segues to a discussion
of U.S. foreign policy: "Currently, the State Department
is attempting to put together a coalition of Iraqui Nationalist
Groups to decide on a future Government, but the Assyrian Christians
as the only non-Islamic group in the mix are at a decided advantage".
Id.
Thus, a full 5 months before UN inspections
were cancelled and the Iraqi war began, this "antiwar activist"
had an inside track on plans for a post-war Iraqi government.
In the January, 2003 Assyrian Christian
Newsletter, Dr. Dan Wooding, founder of ASSIST Ministries, penned
"Ministering to the Assyrians", about a clandestine
missionary trip led by Kenneth Joseph, an American "Western
Assyrian Christian" who "now lives in Japan" to
Baghdad. Joseph, who apparently just returned, went there to
deliver supplies to "the precious Assyrian Christians and
to set up a network to distribute relief once the situation calms".
[25]
He quotes Joseph as having stayed "with
relatives in Baghdad", and being "the only foreigners
in the city without a Government agent. Joseph also claims that
one of his students was working with a UN Agency, "so we
were completely protected and able to work out of the UN Offices
and the Church." Id. Nowhere is there any indication that
Kenneth Joseph was an antiwar activist or human shield.
The Assyrian Christian Newsletter, which
I logged onto on April 2, has since been disabled.
In an article datelined January, 2003,
entitled "The Forgotten Christians of Iraq", a right
wing newsletter emblazoned with the American flag, there is no
mention of a planned trip to Iraq to be a "human shield",
nor antiwar sentiment, nor even the missionary relief trip. He
did, however, state that he was a delegate from Asia to the recent
Assyrian Representation meeting in London, which brought together
Assyrians from Europe, the U.S., Asia and the Middle East for
the first time, to put together a plan for a post-Saddam Iraq".
[26]
It is obvious that Kenneth Joseph has
been involved in long-term policy planning for the future of
Iraq, with an eye upon being a key player in post-war reconstruction.
The Japan Times Connection
Kenneth Joseph's regular newspaper column
is published by Japan Times, for which he has a regular column.
Japan Times is part of the Nifco group, a multinational corporation.
The Chairman of the Board of Nifco is Toshiaki Ogasawara, a member
of the Trilateral Commission from 1992 through 2002. [27]
Ogasawara is a graduate of Princeton,
and serves or has served in some official capacity on the boards
of Bank of America, Avon, Nike, General Electric Japan, Prudential
Asia, and LucasVarity. He is also on the Board of Trustees of
the University of Southern California, and the Board of Governors
of the Pacific Forum, a project of the Center for Strategic and
International Studies (CSIS), where Arnaud de Borchgrave works.
[28], [29].
The index linked to his name lists 36
articles written by Joseph since he started his column in 2002.
[30] None contain any references to antiwar activity, the war
in Iraq, political demonstrations in Japan, or human shields
in general, until April 1, over a week after de Borchgrave's
UPI article.
The Japan Times did print several articles
on human shields arriving in Syria, dateline Damascus, March
29, 2003. They mention two Japanese who left Baghdad after serving
as "human shields", and were staying at a hotel in
Damascus. The delegation was described as having guarded water
purification plants near Baghdad, to symbolically ward off attacks.
The Japanese Embassy said that both were
in good health, and that 41 Japanese were still in Iraq, with
9 still acting as human shields, as reported by the Foreign Ministry.
Remarkably, despite Kenneth Joseph being a staff writer for The
Japan Times, nowhere is this internationally renowned "human
shield" mentioned in his own paper as having joined company
with this Japanese delegation, as reported by de Borchgrave.
[31]
Then there is the matter of Kenneth Joseph's
column in Japan Times.
In the two years that Joseph has written
this column, the first time Joseph mentions the impending war
in Iraq was his February 27 article entitled "Persecuted
for centuries, Iraq's Assyrian Christians once again worry of
their future". [32]
In that article, Joseph calmly and dispassionately
discusses the global political situation, focusing on Assyrian
Christians. He writes about U.S. State Department plans to assemble
a coalition of Iraqi nationalist groups to establish a future
government.
He seems amazingly knowledgeable about
plans for post-war Iraq, making reference to a pan-Assyrian conference
in London, which drew up plans for a post-Hussein Iraq. Discussions
at the conference covered "the establishment of political
priorities for which land would constitute an independent Assyria
and a constitution." This is not the writing of an impassioned,
rather naive peace activist, but rather of a seasoned political
strategist with advance knowledge of the impending war.
On April 1, he wrote an article for Japan
Times, "Many Iraqis see war as their only escape route",
describing a recent trip to Iraq, without giving the dates of
that trip. [33]
He alludes to his antiwar views, and
his newspaper columns on the subject, but paradoxically doesn't
refer to any antiwar articles in column for that paper. Nor does
he mention being part of a delegation, American or Japanese,
to Iraq. Joseph recounts how he "began to talk to some of
the 'human shields' gathered in Baghdad", who are described
as presumptuous, insensitive, and tone-deaf to the needs and
desires of the Iraqi people for freedom, even if it means war
in their land. He notes how the Iraqis were prepared for a loss
of life, perhaps their own.
There's only one thing Kenneth Joseph
doesn't mention: the videotapes.
1. http://www.upi.com/
2. http://www.washtimes.com/
3. For a detailed discussion of Reverend
Moon's organizational history, the brainwashing techniques employed
on cult members, and a profile of his vast, multi-billion dollar
business and media empire, see Releasing the Bonds: Empowering
People to Think for Themselves, by Steve Hassan, one of the original
deputies in the United States to Reverend Moon, who left the
Moon organization and has widely lectured and written of his
experiences in the organization. On the subject of cults, see
also Combatting Cult Mind Control by Steven Hassan, Aitan Publications,
May 2000; the document cited here is from:
HD:Moonorg.doc (WDBN/MSWD) (000A82AE)
A chronology of Reverend Moon's organizational
empire and Church, since his arrival in America in 1971, can
be found at:
HD:FAST-FACTS-Sun Myung Moon.doc (WDBN/MSWD)
(000A82AD)
4. According to Robert Parry, writing
in Consortiumnews.com on October 11, 2000, Rev. Moon's business
empire paid millions of dollars to North Korea's communist leaders
in the early 1990's, when the hard-line government needed foreign
currency to finance its weapons programs, according to U.S. Defense
Intelligence Agency documents. The payments included a $3 million
"birthday present" to current communist leader Kim
Jong Il, and offshore payments amounting to "several tens
of millions of dollars" to the previous communist dictator,
Kim Il Sung.
Besides making alleged payments to North
Korea's communist leaders, the 80-year old founder of the Unification
Church has funneled large sums of money, possibly in the millions
of dollars, to former President George H. Bush. Both Bush Sr.
and Ronad Reagan have close personal ties with Rev. Moon, who
was an honored guest at the Reagan inaugural ceremony.
In recent years, the Moon organization
has made substantial inroads in expanding its media and corporate
power base. Dozens of top politicians, including George Bush
Sr., academics, and media celebrities have accepted paid invitations
to speak for the Moon group, Women's Federation for World Peace,
unwittingly lending prestinge and credibility.
5. Moon.doc (WDBNMSWD)(000A82AD)
http://www.consortiumnews.com/2000/101100a.html
6. De Borchgrave's connections to the
CIA and far right organizations and individuals can be accessed
by a "proximity map" search on the Public Information
Research's website. The search will generate a map, with a background
description for each person or entity on the map:
http://www.namebase.org/
A namebase search on this website for
Arnaud deBorchgrave produced 101 links to government and political
leaders, authors, right wing organizations, and books written
about him. A portion of those listings are as follows:
Covert Action Information Bulletin 1983-#19
(15)
Covert Action Information Bulletin 1985-#23
(24 29 32)
Covert Action Information Bulletin 1980-#10
(39-40)
Covert Action Information Bulletin 1980-#10
(41-42)
Covert Action Information Bulletin 1980-#10
(41-42)
Fairness & Accuracy in Reporting
(FAIR). Extra! 1988-10 (7)
Executive Intelligence Review 1999-04-23
(48)
Resource Center. GroupWatch 1989-CSIS
(1)
Herman,E. O'Sullivan,G. The Terrorism
Industry. 1989 (145)55
Scheim, D. Contract on America. 1988
(324)
Covert Action Quarterly 1999-#68 (62)
Executive Intelligence Review 1999-04-23
(48)
CounterSpy 1982-01 (56)
Marshall,J., The Iran-Contra Connection.
1987 (215)
Parenti, M. Dirty Truths. 1996 (77)
Bradlee,B. A Good Life. 1995 (151)
An excellent overview of the CIA's influence
over the media, which also includes de Borchgrave, can be found
at the Global Intelligence News Portal, which posted an article
entitled "CIA and the Press: The Mighty Wurlitzer",
which can be found at:
http://mprofaca.cro.net/ciapress2.html
7. http://www.washtimes.com/
8.
http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/opinion/
9. http://argument.independent.co.uk/
10. http:www.aim.org/publications/
11. http://www.newsmax.com/
12. The March 24, the National Review,
article, by James S. Robbins, also denounces the antiwar movement
for lacking the moral rectitude of Reverend Joseph:
"Many peace marchers invoked Gandhi
and King, but they will never be subjected to the purifying sacrifices
necessary for true satyagraha. They can afford to do this because
of their confidence that they will be treated humanely...I would
respect the antiwar demonstrators much more if they volunteered
to be human shields in Baghdad, because at least then they would
be putting themselves at genuine risk for their beliefs (Can
we refer to those who do not go overseas for peace as chicken
doves?) If they did so, they might have an epiphany like the
one recently visited on Kenneth Joseph." This can be found
at:
http://www.nationalreview.com/robbins/robbins/032403.asp
13. http://www.philly.com/mid/dailynews/news/local/5318201.htm
14. http://www.newsmax.com/archives/
15. These are websites found on Google:
http://groups.google.com/groupsSee, also:
http://www.agonist.org/
16. http://www.atour.com/religion/docs/20001221d.html
17.http://www.assyrianchristians.com/
18. http://www.capmag.com/article.asp?ID=2631
19. http://assyrianchristians.com/
20. http://assyrianchristians.com/about_ken_joseph.htm
21. The link for the Christian Broadcasting
Network's article is: http://cbn.org/SpiritualLife/churchandministry/
22. The Japan Today interview can be
found at the following link:
http://metropolis.japantoday.com/
23. http://www.biola.edu/admin/alumni/classes.cfm?az=J
24. http:www.thechurchoftheeast.com/news_oct_29_02.htm
25. http://www.christiannewstoday.com/CNTNews85.html
26. http://aanf.org/midwest/jan2003/forgotten_christians.htm
27. http://www.namebase.org/
28. http://cellar.usc.edu:9673/iac2001/speaker?rec_id=4
29. http:www.usc.edu/about/administration/trustees/
30.http://www.japantimes.co.jp/
The list of the 36 articles written by
Ken Joseph for Japan Times, his regular newspaper column in Japan,
since 2002, are as follows, and can be found at the following
website:
* Taking issue with a visa 'investigation'
March 18, 2003
* Homesickness, toll-free numbers and
money orders March 4, 2003
"There are 2 million of our fellow
Assyrian Christians in Iraq. They need our prayers at this time.
The best way to appreciate all we have in Japan? Leave for a
little bit! I'm homesick already."
No mention of "war".
* Persecuted for centuries, Iraq's Assyrian
Christians once again wary of their future February 27, 2003
He expresses concern about the effects
of instability on Assyrians if there is a regime change. While
he sounds ambivalent about regime change here, he seems more
afraid of it than not.
* A kind word, visa sponsorship and tax
refunds February 18, 2003
* Refunded cash for working at home and
a sumo day out February 4, 2003
* Leaving Japan, getting organized and
cash refunds January 21, 2003
* Pension posers, recycling visas, and
a re-entry tip-off January 14, 2003
* Getting cash reimbursed for medical
costs December 17, 2002
December 10, 2002 No mention of "war"
or "Iraq"
* Can tourists get themselves working
visas? December 3, 2002
* Visa rules and looking for a dream
job November 15, 2002
* A good result with Japan's health insurance
system November 1, 2002
No mention of "war" or "Iraq",
nor of the international conference he had just attended in London,
and mentioned on the Assyrian Christian News website
* Insuring your health; ensuring your
privacy October 18, 2002
* Finding out more about the law and
you in Japan October 4, 2002
* Check-up costs, parking perils, and
'quake advice September 19, 2002
* Reaching out to Japanese hit on Sept.
11 September 5, 2002
* Divorce issues, cheap traveling and
getting ADSL September 5, 2002
* Seeking medical redress and keeping
control of Spam August 22, 2002
* Looking after your mental and physical
well-being in Japan August 8, 2002
* Prominent figures raise questions over
numbering system August 8, 2002
* Health insurance, pension cash claims
and odd-job search July 25, 2002
* When the 'Big One' hits, help will
be close at hand July 25, 2002
* Permanent status and foreign driving
licences in Japan July 11, 2002
* Seeking a foreign channel July 4, 2002
* Newshungry TV viewers fighting for
English service June 27, 2002
* Getting your just rewards for a lifetime
of slog June 13, 2002
* The fuss-free way to get you and your
stuff home May 30, 2002
* Lifelines May 16, 2002
* Welcome to a new page, welcome to a
new column May 9, 2002
* Religious site July 24, 2001
* All in a (24-hour) day's work June
24, 2001
* Help is on the way June 24, 2001
* Parents driven to 'kidnap' children
December 13, 2000
* JET sends third relief mission to Turkey
August 24, 1999
* Volunteers struck by refugees' fortitude
May 18, 1999
31. http://www.japantimes.co.jp/
32. Kenneth Joseph's February 27 Japan
Times article can be found at:
http://www.japantimes.co.jp/
33. http://www.japantimes.co.jp/
Yesterday's
Features
Zoltan
Grossman
The Perils of Occupation: the Easier
the Victory, the Harder the Peace
Uri
Avnery
The Night After
Wayne Madsen
The Telltale Signs of Empire
David Krieger
Before You Become Too Flushed with Victory, Think of Ali Ismaeel
Abbas
Jeremy
Brecher
What Can the World Do Now That Tanks Prowl Baghdad?
Robert
Jensen
The Unseen War
Geoffrey
Neale
Ashcroft's War on the Constitution:
A Patriot Attack on America
Jeffrey
St. Clair
Last Tango in Baghdad
Hammond
Guthrie
Rumors of War
Joseph
Heller
Nately's Old Man
Steve
Perry
War Web Log 4/10
Website
of the Day
The
Third Page
Keep CounterPunch
Alive:
Make
a Tax-Deductible Donation Today Online!
home / subscribe
/ about us / books
/ archives / search
/ links /
|